They were supposed to be soulmates — or at least, that’s what millions believed for over two decades. Carrie and Mr. Big: messy, passionate, wrong, then finally… right. But a recently leaked message from HBO’s internal servers is shaking that foundation to its core. Because Mr. Big’s final text wasn’t meant for Carrie. It was sent to Natasha.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(638x219:640x221)/bridget-moynahan-1-5e42585d72fa4bb2a361ec16f18e7f43.jpg)
According to behind-the-scenes sources, the message was retrieved from a data backup of Big’s phone — the same device used during flashback filming for And Just Like That. The text was short. Just one devastating line: “I made the wrong choice. It was always you.”
No one knows if Carrie ever saw it. But when the show aired, fans were confused by Carrie’s sudden urge to contact and meet with Natasha — the ex who was supposed to be “the closed chapter” in Big’s chaotic romantic history. Now, it all starts to make painful sense.
An anonymous producer admitted, “We came across that message while pulling assets for post-production, but HBO instructed us not to include it.” When cornered by reporters, Natasha declined to comment, only offering: “I’m not ready to talk about things that still hurt.”
Meanwhile, fans are split. Some fiercely defend Carrie — the woman who stood by Big as he died. Others believe: “He didn’t die in the arms of the one he loved. He died thinking of the one he never forgot.”
One more detail is adding fuel to the emotional fire: In the episode where Carrie visits Natasha’s office, she later sits quietly in a bathroom stall, red-eyed and visibly shaken. At the time, audiences assumed it was unresolved guilt. But now, people are asking: Did Carrie know more than she let on? Did she discover the message… and choose silence over truth?
